On the south end of the Island you’ll find Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant at 201 Gulf Drive N. Oma’s offers big floppy slices of pizza along with many of the traditional family style Italian specialties.
Solo’s Pizza in Holmes Beach
This casual restaurant is located in the Anna Maria Island Shops plaza at 3244 East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach. Solo’s is a mix between a pizza joint and a sports bar. They also have thin sliced pizza, sandwiches and pub grub fare.
The Feast in Holmes Beach
Not only can you find great pizza here, but also an assortment of great seafood and something for everyone. The Feast is casual, but slightly higher end. This isn’t really a pizza place, but an nice restaurant that also offers fantastic pizza pies. Find the Feast in the Island Shopping Center at 5406 Marina Drive.
Island Grill in Holmes Beach
Located at 5910 Marina Drive, Island Grill has something for everyone. Find great pizzas along with a wide selection of menu items. This restaurant is always offering daily specials, so be sure to ask.
Pizza Social in Anna Maria
Find this quick and easy pizza place at 308 Pine Avenue. Formerly J Burns, Pizza Social is a small pizza shop that offers hand crafted pizzas (including gluten free crust option), and fresh salads.
Amazing Pizza Just off the Island
Danny’s Pizzeria in Bradenton
Located at 7220 Manatee Avenue in West Bradenton, Danny’s is a very popular spot among locals. They serve delicious thin crust pizza, sandwiches and delicious Italian specialties for dinner. Excellent pizza and wings along with a great meatball! Danny’s also offers pizza by the slice.