This information page provides Anna Maria Island top ten ice cream shops. Well summer is here once again! Nothing is better than spending a day on the beach soaking up the warm Florida Sun, and swimming in the Gulf of Mexico. One of my favorite things to do after a day at the beach, and one of the best ways to cool down during the summer heat on Anna Maria Island is to grab an ice cream treat. So I spent the day traveling the Island in search of the best ice cream and candy treats in the area.
There’s nothing better than treating yourself to some delicious, cold ice cream on a hot and humid Florida day. Which may be the reason why there is quite a selection of ice cream options on Anna Maria Island. Here are all the ice cream shops the Island has to offer, and which Island city they’re located in:
Anna Maria City:
- Two Scoops Ice Cream (101 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria, FL 34216)
- Dips Ice Cream (503 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216)
- Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery (9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216)
- Holy Cow Ice Cream (3234 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217)
- Small Town Creamery (5404 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, Florida)
- Island Scoops (103B Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217)
- Joe’s Eats & Sweets (219 Gulf Dr S, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217)
Serving ice cream, gourmet sodas, baked goods, and much more is Island Scoops in Bradenton Beach. Island Scoops sells Big Olaf ice cream, which is hand mixed by local Amish craftsmen and absolutely to die for. Seriously, visitors return year after year for some of the best homemade ice cream Florida has to offer. With about 20 different flavors always on the menu, coming to your final decision may be a bit difficult.
Dutch Peanut Butter
Coconut Almond Joy
Aside from ice cream, they also carry tons of assorted candy, baked goods, and retro gourmet sodas. Some baked good items include cupcakes, gourmet pies, cookies, etc. They have anything and everything sugary and sweet, except their sugar-free ice cream of course.
Island Scoops is open everyday, from 1PM – 10PM. Check out their full menu!
For more ice cream options, check out this blog that lists all the ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island.
Baked goods and sugary goodness is what you’re in store for at Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery. Located toward the North end of the Island, this shop is just two blocks before Pine Ave. Here you will find Handmade Italian gelato, premium soft serve, and sorbettes. Among classic bakery items like croissants and danishes, this bakery also sells William Dean truffles (known from the Hunger Games).
Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery
This family owned business uses fresh fruit and local dairy. They even produce their gelato on site! If you’re a chocolate lover, you’ll appreciate the fact that they have 8 different chocolate based flavors. Or you could go for their delicious dairy-free sorbetto. The kiddos will really enjoy the customized sundaes they do. Now lets talk about the bakery aspect of the Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery.
The bakery offers danishes, croissants, and more! Though, this bakery also carries a very unique product, William Dean truffles. These truffles are known for their flavor combos, like peanut butter & jelly, port & fig, etc. In fact, you can choose from 36 flavors of the William Dean truffles.
9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216
Open from 10am – 10pm everyday
If you liked this blog (and ice cream), then you’ll definitley apprecaite our “Ice Cream Options on Anna Maria Island” blog.
If the bright & fun colors of the building don’t get your attention, then the tasty treats inside sure will. Joe’s Eats & Sweets is an adorable stop in Bradenton Beach that will have your taste buds happy you stopped by. Homemade ice cream, sundaes, and fudge is what they specialize in. The selection of ice cream flavors include classics like chocolate, strawberry, and mint chip, but they also have key lime cheesecake, cotton candy and nerds, pineapple coconut, and even almond turtle fudge. And the list goes on!
Sundae options include over 15 different, delicious concoctions. Two of my favorites are the Coffee Lovers Dream, which contains coffee ice cream, of course, topped with coffee syrup, whipped cream (the real stuff), and a cherry. My second favorite Brownie Sundae, mainly because it comes with a homemade walnut brownie.
End your evening out with a stop here after dinner on Bridge Street, or come over after a day at the beach.
Check out our blog, “Ice Cream Options on Anna Maria Island” for details on all the local ice cream shops.
Dips Ice Cream, located at 503 Pine Ave in Anna Maria, has been serving Anna Maria Island delicious ice cream since 1993. Though this ice cream shop is more than just a place to go for a sugar rush. Dips is also a candy & sports shop.
Adults will enjoy the many throwback candies, including bottle caps, wax lips and jaw breakers. Kids will like the dotted ice cream pellets and general abundance of delicious refined sugar. And with over 30 flavors of ice cream (including non-dairy), you’re sure to find a treat you’ll enjoy! Did I mention they also have Mango and Tangerine Italian ice? Because they do, and it is the perfect way to cool down on one of Florida’s hot summer days.
Anna Maria Island is home to the Holmes Beach Holy Cow Ice Cream shop, one of the best ice cream stops in the area. It is also a great gift shop too! With a tiki lounge and a kids area, Holy Cow Ice Cream is also a perfect place to go with the family.
While you’re there make sure to try one of my personal favorites, their famous handmade chocolates.
Holy Cow Ice Cream is located on Holmes Beach in the same shopping complex as Walgreens. Swing on by with the whole family and enjoy some delicious frozen treats!
Navigating to Holy Cow Ice Cream On Anna Maria Island
Facebook for Holy Cow
3234 East Bay Drive
Holmes Beach, FL34217
1950‘s Palm Beach elegance and style meets the tranquil low-key lifestyle of Anna Maria Island. The Shiny Fish Emporium is the inspiration of Creative Director Rebecca Preston. The Shiny Fish welcomes you to a shopping experience in which you’ll find the latest treasures that Rebecca can’t wait to share with you.
Lots of Candy and Gifts at Shiny Fish Emporium on Pine Avenue
Walk through the door and be transported to an irresistible place, where Beach Glam© gifts are found next to unique toys for kids of all ages. Candy hued pom-pom beach cover ups, tropical scented candles, award winning Glenda Geis handbags, and mini surfboards are just a few of this shop’s treasures.
Bring home one of our original “sugared” sand dollars, hand-painted by Rebecca–or slip into Shiny Fish’s original home-grown line of gem T-shirts for kids and adults. Visit the shops’ porch window display to see an array of the latest fun and funny designs for kids.
Shiny Fish offers Beach Glam© decorating services: from the Jonathan Adler furniture, lighting and accessories line, to one-of-a-kind mid-century finds. Ask Rebecca about her exciting new line of custom decorating pieces straight from Hollywood to your home. Come in barefoot, or pop on a pair of bling seahorse Havianas, and enjoy a refreshing tropical ice cream bubble, while relaxing on our dill pickle lounge couch…
Are you wondering what a tropical ice cream bubble is? Well then stop in and see Rebecca at the Shiny Fish Emporium on Pine Avenue today! Shiny Fish Emporium on Pine Avenue made our top ten ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island Blog!
Shiny Fish Emporium
306C Pine Avenue
Anna Maria, FL 34207